Award-winning sheep's milk cheese and yogurt are celebrated for their uniqueness and distinctive flavors.

​Recently celebrating 20 years of business, Old Chatham Sheepherding Company is continually growing and striving to produce the highest quality sheep's milk products on the market.

1st Place - Sheep's Milk Yogurt - Plain

2nd Place - Ricotta

2nd Place - Hudson Valley Camembert Square

3rd Place - Gatekeeper (w/ Crown Finish Caves)

3rd Place - Ewe's Blue

​​BLACK SHEEP CHEESE & YOGURT

OLD CHATHAM SHEEPHERDING CREAMERY